|
|

Mr. Flaherty is sorryArticle By: Gordon Pape
The Finance Minister regrets having wiped out more than $30 billion (and counting) from the savings of Canadians. For some reason, his apology isn't appeasing angry seniors.
Earlier this month, RBC Capital Markets published an analysis of the impact of the income trusts decision on investors. It concluded that the massive meltdown of more than $30 billion we've seen so far is only the beginning. By the time the new tax takes effect in 2011, the report concluded, Canadian investors collectively will likely suffer losses of up to $60 billion in the market capitalization of business and energy trusts in order, in the words of the report, “to achieve theoretical tax neutrality”. That's an astounding figure and no one should try to sugar-coat it with words like “it's only on paper”. This is the major and permanent destruction of personal wealth and the primary victims are hard-working Canadians who did exactly what they were told to do by saving for their retirement years and investing the money according to the rules laid down by successive governments. I am frankly appalled by some of the insensitive comments I have read in the media saying in effect that all this is somehow the investors' own fault. These folks did nothing illegal or even borderline. They invested in securities that were publicly traded in Canada and which met all legal tests. They paid taxes on the income they received in accordance with the laws of the land. This is not a case of people trying to hide money in offshore tax havens (the next target on our Finance Minister's hit list) or trying to cheat the Canada Revenue Agency by using overly-aggressive tax shelters. Yet these people are being demonized by some writers as somehow being the cause of the problem. As one senior wrote, in dripping sarcasm, after reading some of these articles: “When I think back and realize what a money grubbing old man I was for trying to maximize my income to earn as much as I could on my invested capital and life savings, it's truly humiliating! Here I was complaining just because I had lost a measly $165,000 of my lifetime's hard-earned capital in just two days. It didn't matter that I was in my 70s and my ‘payroll' days were over. After all, I still had some money left. Some people just never have enough. Now you know why I feel so guilty.”
© November 2006 Gordon Pape Enterpries Ltd.
|
| 50Plus Money Forums
|
|---|
Investing |
Consumer issues |
Money-saving tips |